|
From the evening performance on 19th June 2008. "Marguerite" demonstrates
precisely why lesser producers settle for shoe-horning popular band repertoires
into ludicrous storylines. It is the easy, and often lazy, way out because a
proper musical has so many more elements the creative team need to balance in
order to achieve success.
With great bravery, this team come very close to an enormous hit. Several
strong numbers (Ruthie Henshall's "China Doll" almost worth the ticket price
alone) and impressively atmospheric, yet simple, staging are a solid foundation.
The character-acting abilities of Matt Cross and Andrew C. Wadsworth; vocal
skill of Annalene Beechey and sheer stage presence of Alexander Hanson are added
advantages. A short running time also guarantees the audience attention too.
The weakness is not the common one of a poor book, but how characters develop
in each of the three storylines. Marguerite herself links them - and the show
springs into life during "Intoxication" when they touch most overtly.
Opportunities to do this earlier in the performance are lost and seldom grabbed
again, a real pity as it reduces most characters to unnecessarily shallow and
fleeting appearances. Even Marguerite's central love interests are given little
opportunity to explain why they are willing to change lives for her. Sadly, this
means we have to infer more than usual and never truly understand characters'
motivations nor care deeply enough for the inevitable ending to have the impact
its perfect staging demands.
This is a production that needs to be seen twice. Gentle in its initial
impact, it should reward repeat viewing as the characters become familiar.
Certainly the monkey found it helpful knowing several songs before it went in,
and when the show really worked it would have appreciated greater time to
reflect. Hopefully this will have life after the initial Haymarket run as, with
a short running time, there is plenty of space to cultivate a quite beguiling
evening still further.
|