|
(Updated review, from the current Garrick Theatre production on 15th November
2011) Theatremonkey will now present the case for and against the show
"Chicago":
For the prosecution: This show has been squeezed onto far too small a stage.
There is less room in front of the orchestra for the dancers to move, thus
diminishing the visual impact somewhat. Second, the dancers themselves appear
not to be at the "Fosse" level any longer. There's a distinct lack of
co-ordinated movement and discipline in the 'lines' that Fosse was so keen on -
and there's less matching of height and build to make some spectacular
choreography look untidier than it need be. Finally, US import America Ferrera
is still very much 'finding her feet' as a musical theatre performer - easily
outclassed in singing and dancing by co-stars Amara-Faye Wright and Darius
Campbell.
For the defence: America Ferrera is so simply loveable on stage that any
shortcomings are forgiven in an instant, and there is no doubt that once she
relaxes she'll wring as much fun out of her solos as she does already from her
duet work with the revelation that is Darius Campbell. Forget the immature fool
of TV Reality shows, this man has matured into a superb musical theatre
character actor. Commanding the stage and producing unforgettable moments with
Ms Roxie whenever they are paired, his work is unmissable. For energy, he is
matched by Ms Amara-Faye Wright and in musical acting skills by Jasna Ivir and
James Doherty as Mama Morton and Amos Hart respectively.
Summary and Judgement: If the whole feels a trifle tired, the show still
packs enough punch to justify its existence even after all these years. Much of
the current casting is worthy of your time, and the monkey overturns its
previous verdict. In other words, on appeal, Judge Theatremonkey finds this
appealing... Go see, if only for the
central cast performances.
________________________________________________________
(From the Adelphi Theatre production)
This was a miss in the 1970's - ahead of its time as the 'dark' musical was just
being born. Second time around it is a hit. We all know "All That Jazz", and
whistle it on the way in. Of the rest, "Mr Cellophane" is a clear winner!
On the minus side, theatremonkey felt that when you had seen one skimpily clad
dancer, you had seen them all. The staging is a model of simplicity, but the
whole thing fails to sustain the interest.
|